Trusted Labor Arbitrator & Employment Dispute Specialist serving Michigan, Georgia, Illinois and Nationwide
Email: efcornelius@comcast.net
Telephone: 478-731-7643
Labor Arbitration
Labor Arbitration Services for Employers, Unions, and Public Agencies
Experienced, impartial arbitration for workplace disputes involving collective bargaining agreements, discipline, contract interpretation, and employment policies.
Labor arbitration is a widely recognized alternative to litigation in which a neutral third party hears evidence and issues a decision that is binding on the parties.
Dr. E. Frank Cornelius provides professional arbitration services across the private sector, public sector, and federal government, accepting appointments nationwide.
What Is Labor Arbitration?
Labor arbitration is an out-of-court dispute resolution process used to resolve disagreements between labor and management by presenting the matter to an impartial arbitrator whose decision is binding.
It is designated in collective bargaining agreements as the method for resolving disputes when grievance negotiations fail.
Collective bargaining agreements contain grievance procedures that culminate in binding arbitration if the parties cannot resolve the issue internally.
Why organizations choose arbitration:
-
Typically less formal than court proceedings, usually resulting in faster, cheaper resolution.
-
Provides a structured mechanism for interpreting labor contracts.
-
Produces enforceable decisions under state or federal law.
For unionized workplaces, arbitration is frequently the final step in the grievance process — making the selection of an experienced arbitrator critically important.
Types of Labor Arbitration
Understanding the categories of labor arbitration helps parties choose the right neutral.
Grievance (Rights) Arbitration
Resolves disputes involving the interpretation or application of an existing labor contract, including issues such as discipline, discharge, seniority, or work assignments.
It is considered a final and binding process addressing disagreements during the life of a collective agreement.
Interest Arbitration
Used when negotiators reach an impasse while creating a new labor contract and need a third party to determine which provisions will be included.
Common Labor Disputes
Heard in Arbitration
A grievance typically arises when either the union or employer questions the interpretation or enforcement of a collective bargaining agreement or alleges a violation of its provisions.
Typical matters include:
-
Employee discipline and termination
-
Contract interpretation
-
Workplace policy enforcement
-
Seniority disputes
-
Work assignments
-
Performance evaluations
-
Management rights
Grievances generally begin within internal procedures
and proceed to arbitration if unresolved.
Labor Arbitration
with Dr. E. Frank Cornelius
Dr. Cornelius arbitrates labor and employment disputes and has authored arbitration opinions cited by federal courts, other arbitrators, legal treatises, law reviews, and American Bar Association materials.
He holds a PhD in mathematics from the University of Washington and a Juris Doctor from the University of Michigan after earning a mathematics degree from MIT.
His specialties include:
-
Labor disputes
-
Employee benefits cases, including withdrawal liability
-
Technical and scientific arbitrations
Published arbitration opinions appear in major legal reporters and research databases such as Bloomberg BNA and Westlaw.
Representative
Labor Arbitration Matters
Recent published matters include cases involving:
-
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers and City of Springfield (2026)
-
Fraternal Order of Police and City of Columbia (2025)
-
UAW Local 9699 and Auria St. Clair, LLC (2024)
-
International Brotherhood of Teamsters and Nestlé USA (2024)
-
Federal Bureau of Prisons disciplinary disputes
Parties benefit from working with an arbitrator whose decisions are recognized within leading arbitration reporting systems.
Why Experience Matters
in Labor Arbitration
Because arbitration decisions are binding and enforceable, selecting a neutral with proven analytical ability and decision-writing experience is essential.
Dr. Cornelius’ academic background and scholarly work contribute to a rigorous, evidence-driven approach to dispute resolution.
Differentiators:
-
Neutral, independent decision-maker
-
Experienced across public and private sectors
-
Skilled in complex and technical matters
-
Nationwide availability
Who Retains a Labor Arbitrator?
Labor arbitration is typically invoked by an employer or a union after grievance procedures fail to resolve a workplace dispute.
Clients commonly include:
-
Labor unions
-
Private employers
-
Public agencies
-
Federal entities
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a labor arbitrator do?
A labor arbitrator is a neutral third party who resolves workplace disputes between unions and employers. The arbitrator conducts a hearing, reviews evidence, interprets the collective bargaining agreement, and issues a written decision that determines the outcome of the dispute. If parties so desire, instead of a hearing, they may submit their case to the arbitrator on a written stipulation of facts.
Is labor arbitration legally binding?
Labor arbitration is binding, meaning both parties are required to follow the arbitrator’s decision. Binding arbitration provides a final resolution and helps avoid lengthy and costly court proceedings.
When should a union request arbitration?
A union should request arbitration after the grievance process has been completed and the dispute remains unresolved. Arbitration is often the final step for disagreements involving discipline, contract interpretation, wages, benefits, or working conditions.
How long does labor arbitration take?
The timeline for labor arbitration varies based on the complexity of the case and scheduling availability. Many disputes are resolved within a few months, while more complex matters may require additional time for hearings and a written decision.
What types of disputes are handled in labor arbitration?
Labor arbitration typically addresses grievances involving management rights, employee discipline, termination, seniority, job assignments, workplace policies, compensation, benefits, and the interpretation of collective bargaining agreements. Some cases may involve statutory rights and responsibilities.
What are the advantages of labor arbitration?
Labor arbitration is generally more efficient and less formal than litigation. It allows the parties to select an experienced decision-maker, promotes faster resolutions, and provides a structured process designed specifically for workplace disputes.
Who selects the labor arbitrator?
The arbitrator is usually selected through mutual agreement between the union and employer or from a recognized arbitration panel. This collaborative selection process helps ensure neutrality and professional qualifications.
Can both sides present evidence during arbitration?
Yes. Both parties have the opportunity to present testimony, submit documents, call witnesses, and make arguments during the hearing. Parties typically also want to submit legal briefs supporting their respective positions. This ensures a fair process before the arbitrator issues a decision.
Is labor arbitration confidential?
Although procedures vary, arbitration is typically more private than courtroom litigation. This discretion helps protect sensitive workplace information and limits unnecessary public exposure.
What is the difference between labor arbitration and mediation?
Labor arbitration and mediation are both forms of alternative dispute resolution, but they serve different roles. In mediation, a neutral facilitator helps the parties negotiate a voluntary agreement. In arbitration, the arbitrator hears evidence and issues a decision that typically resolves the dispute. Arbitration provides a definitive outcome when negotiations fail.
Can an arbitration decision be appealed?
Arbitration decisions are generally final and subject to very limited judicial review. Courts rarely overturn an arbitration award unless there is evidence of fraud, procedural misconduct, or the arbitrator exceeded their authority. This finality is one reason many organizations prefer arbitration over litigation.
What should employers expect during labor arbitration?
Employers should expect a structured process that includes pre-hearing preparation, presentation of evidence, witness testimony, and legal arguments. After the hearing concludes, the arbitrator evaluates the record and issues a written decision. Preparation and clear documentation are key factors in an effective presentation.
What should unions expect during the arbitration process?
Unions can expect a fair and impartial hearing where both sides have the opportunity to present evidence and advocate their position. The arbitrator evaluates the facts in light of the collective bargaining agreement and applicable workplace standards before issuing a decision.
When is arbitration required under a collective bargaining agreement?
Collective bargaining agreements designate arbitration as the final step in the grievance procedure. When internal resolution efforts do not settle the dispute, arbitration is invoked to provide a neutral and enforceable determination.
Why do organizations choose arbitration instead of going to court?
Organizations often choose arbitration because it is more efficient, more predictable, and handled by a decision-maker experienced in labor relations. The process is designed to resolve workplace disputes professionally while minimizing operational disruption.
Is labor arbitration used in both the public and private sectors?
Yes. Labor arbitration is widely used across private companies, public agencies, and unionized workplaces. It is considered a trusted method for resolving disputes while maintaining ongoing working relationships.