top of page
Image by Markus Winkler

Employee Benefits

About

Employee Benefits Arbitration for Plan Sponsors, Plan Administrators, Employers, Unions, Plans, and Funds

Experienced, neutral arbitration for disputes involving pension and welfare benefits plans, 401(k) plans, ERISA matters, withdrawal liability, and complex benefits obligations.

Employee benefits arbitration provides a structured alternative to litigation for resolving disputes involving pension and welfare benefits plans, multiemployer funds, 401(k) plans, and statutory benefits obligations.


Dr. E. Frank Cornelius delivers professional arbitration services for high-stakes benefits matters requiring analytical precision, financial literacy, and legal insight, accepting appointments nationwide.

What Is Employee
Benefits Arbitration?

Employee benefits arbitration is a dispute resolution process in which a neutral arbitrator evaluates evidence and issues a decision regarding conflicts tied to retirement and welfare benefits plans, 401(k) plans, benefit funds, and related statutory responsibilities. Arbitration is especially effective in settling participants’ disputed claims for benefits.  

​

These cases often involve detailed financial data, regulatory frameworks, and long-term funding considerations, making subject-matter experience essential.

​

Arbitration offers organizations a private forum to resolve sensitive benefits disputes without prolonged courtroom proceedings.

​

Why organizations choose arbitration:

  • Enables informed review of complex financial evidence

  • Often resolves disputes faster than litigation

  • Provides a neutral forum for highly technical matters

  • Produces enforceable outcomes
     

For organizations managing pension, welfare, 401(k), and other benefits obligations, arbitration provides a reliable mechanism for resolving financially significant disputes with clarity and finality.

Types of Employee
Benefits Arbitration

Understanding the categories of benefits arbitration helps parties select the appropriate resolution path.
 

Pension and Withdrawal Liability Arbitration

Addresses disputes involving single employer, multiple employer, multiemployer pension and welfare benefits plans, 401(k) plans, employer withdrawal liability calculations, and funding responsibilities under federal statutes.
 

Benefits Plan Interpretation Arbitration

Resolves conflicts concerning eligibility, plan language, contribution requirements, and the administration of benefits programs.

 

Executive Benefits Arbitration

Non-qualified benefits plans for executives.
 

Common Benefits Disputes
Heard in Arbitration

Benefits disputes frequently arise when plan obligations, contribution structures, or statutory requirements are questioned.
 

Typical matters include:

  • Benefits eligibility determinations

  • Plan interpretation conflicts

  • Compliance-related disputes

  • Pension contribution disputes

  • Funding responsibility disagreements

  • Actuarial calculation challenges

  • Withdrawal liability assessments

     

These matters often proceed to arbitration when

regulatory frameworks or plan terms require neutral review.

Employee Benefits Arbitration
with Dr. E. Frank Cornelius

Dr. Cornelius arbitrates labor and employment disputes and has authored arbitration opinions cited by federal courts, other arbitrators, legal treatises, law reviews, and American Bar Association publications.

​

He holds a PhD in mathematics from the University of Washington and a Juris Doctor from the University of Michigan after earning a mathematics degree from MIT.

​

His specialties include:

  • Labor disputes

  • Employee benefits cases, including withdrawal liability

  • Technical and scientific arbitrations

​
 

Published arbitration opinions appear in major legal reporters and

research platforms such as Bloomberg BNA and Westlaw.

Representative Benefits
Arbitration Matters

Matters have included disputes involving:

  • Claims for benefits

  • Multiemployer pension obligations

  • Employer withdrawal assessments

  • Fringe benefit contribution issues

  • Plan administration conflicts


Parties benefit from working with an arbitrator experienced in analyzing financial models, statutory frameworks, and long-term benefit structures.
 

Why Experience Matters
in Benefits Arbitration

Employee benefits disputes often hinge on complex calculations, regulatory interpretations by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), Department of Labor (DOL), and Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC), and detailed documentation.

​

Selecting a neutral decision-maker with strong analytical capabilities helps ensure decisions are grounded in both financial logic and legal reasoning.

​

Dr. Cornelius’ academic background supports a rigorous, evidence-driven approach to technically demanding cases.

Differentiators:

  • Neutral, independent decision-maker

  • Strong analytical and quantitative expertise

  • Experienced in complex statutory matters

  • Nationwide availability
     

Who Retains an
Benefits Arbitrator?

Benefits arbitration is commonly initiated when employers, unions, plan sponsors, or funds require a binding determination regarding financial obligations or plan interpretation.

​

Clients commonly include:

  • Plan sponsors

  • Employers

  • Unions

  • Multiemployer funds

  • Public entities

  • Federal organizations
     

Frequently Asked Questions

What is employee benefits arbitration?
Employee benefits arbitration is a private dispute resolution process in which a neutral arbitrator decides conflicts involving pension plans, 401(k) plans, benefits funds, withdrawal liability, and related statutory obligations enforced by IRS, DOL, and PBGC.

​

What types of pension disputes go to arbitration?
Common pension disputes include withdrawal liability assessments, contribution requirements, plan interpretation disagreements, actuarial calculations, and eligibility determinations.

​

Is withdrawal liability arbitration required?
Yes. Under federal law, Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act (MPPAA), disputes over withdrawal liability from multiemployer pension plans are resolved through mandatory arbitration.

​

Who uses benefits arbitration?
Employers, plan sponsors, pension funds, unions, and public entities often use arbitration to resolve complex financial disputes tied to benefits programs.

​

Are benefits arbitration decisions binding?
Most decisions are binding and enforceable, providing parties with a definitive resolution without extended litigation.

​

Why is specialized expertise important in benefits arbitration?
Benefits disputes frequently involve financial models, actuarial data, and regulatory interpretation, making analytical experience critical for sound decision-making.

​

How long does benefits arbitration take?
Timelines vary depending on complexity, but arbitration often concludes faster and costs less than court proceedings due to more streamlined procedures.

​

Is benefits arbitration confidential?
Yes. Arbitration is generally conducted in a private setting, helping protect sensitive financial and organizational information.

​

When should a benefits dispute move to arbitration?
Arbitration is appropriate when plan terms, statutory rules, or funding obligations are contested and internal resolution is unsuccessful.

​

bottom of page